Saturday, September 14, 2013

ADHD in a Positive Light

Sherman, J., Rasmussen, C., & Baydala, L. (2006). Think positively: How some characteristics of ADHD can be adaptive and accepted in the classroom. Childhood Education, 82(4), 196+. Retrieved from http://www.questia.com/read/1G1-145388318/thinking-positively-how-some-characteristics-of-adhd
            
            According to Sherman, Rasmussen, and Baydala (2006), Attention deficit/hyperactivity
disorder (ADHD)  is described by most sources as a disorder negatively characterized by its deficits and difficulties which can dishearten the children diagnosed and discourage parents as well as educators.  As stated by Sherman, Rasmussen, and Baydala (2006), researched through MTA Cooperative Group (1999), “ADHD occurs in 3 to 5 percent of school-age children, making it the most common psychiatric disorder among children” (p. 196).  Students diagnosed with ADHD may have difficulties in school with “…creating and maintaining social relations, low self-esteem, and deficits in the area of executive functioning” (Sherman, Rasmussen & Baydala, 2006, p. 196). 
            Despite the negative connotations associated with ADHD, new research has indicated that some behaviors exhibited in those with ADHD can be “…potentially adaptive in some situations and contexts” (Sherman, Rasmussen & Baydala, 2006, p. 196).  Instead of viewing ADHD as a disorder classified by its deficits, it can be seen as an advantage illustrating potential and unique characteristics.  It is suggested by Sherman, Rasmussen, and Baydala (2006) that educators should strive to “…identify the unique ADHD characteristics of each child, and tailor their instruction and teaching behaviors to emphasize the child’s strengths and abilities” (p. 197).  Children with ADHD are known to be “polyactive” and can work simultaneously on numerous tasks.  They are excellent brainstormers who can lead a variety of tasks with energy and enthusiasm.   By providing students with ADHD opportunities to exuberate their energy through special errands, multi-sensory activities and through the use of various media, teachers can keep students engaged.  Shortening tasks and instructions, re-arranging desks and including interesting stimuli can also aid students with ADHD in reaching their creative, academic and behavioral goals (Sherman, Rasmussen & Baydala, 2006, p. 198).  Even though in the medical profession ADHD is viewed as a disorder, maintaining an optimistic attitude can help parents and educators focus on the children’s strengths and unique leaning styles rather than on the stigmatic diagnosis.
            Unfortunately within my teaching community there is a negative stigma attached to the ADHD label.  Whenever a teacher discovers that a student in her classroom is showing “classic ADHD signs,” the sighs and complaints begin within the walls of the faculty lounge.  Hence the reason I do not eat lunch often in the faculty lounge.  Whenever this topic arises, I often ask my colleague if she has tried incorporating activities with a variety of multiple intelligences.  From my time at Trinity as an undergrad, it has always been stressed that every child learns differently and instruction needs to be differentiated to meet your students’ needs.  It is disheartening to think that some of my former teachers at my current school have forgotten this.  I enjoyed reading about children with ADHD in a positive light and would strongly recommend my fellow faculty members to read this journal article.
            This journal article shed some light on the negative way in which ADHD is represented.  I agree that society, including teachers, tend to focus on the limitations or difficulties that children with ADHD experience.  I enjoyed how the article celebrated the unique characteristics and strengths that students with ADHD have within the classroom.  The journal article provided useful tools for teachers on how to promote positive learning experiences for children with ADHD.  It was also interesting to reflect on how some of the most creative and influential people of the past may in fact been diagnosed with ADHD.  What would have happened if the works of Mozart, Dali, or Einstein were stifled?  This journal concentrated more on the practical strategies of helping students with ADHD and less on the medical jargon associated with the disorder.  It is more suited for parents and educators rather than those in the medical field.

7 comments:

  1. Your journal review was interesting and I particularly enjoyed the topic of the journal that you chose. It is uncommon to hear positivity about students with ADHD even though they are often very bright. I also don’t eat lunch in the teachers’ lounge as I am uncomfortable with some of the conversations that take place. I think I would like to read this article because your review says that it is more suited for parents and educators and I would like to know some of the practical strategies that would help students with ADHD. Occasionally, I have parents that will ask for help with their child at home. They will state that they can’t get their child to sit still and focus long enough to complete their homework. It seems that this article would be a good recommended read for parents looking for help.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I liked your critique of this article. I especially like how you said students with ADHD should be looked at as special and a gift to the class, rather than a problem. I think you really hammered home the idea that these students are not to be gossiped about or looked at as distractions from the other students. Sometimes we as educators have a tendency to do that.

    Greg

    ReplyDelete
  3. Jennifer,
    Thanks for this positive post and article! The last 2 years I have had 2 different students with pretty severe cases of ADHD in my classroom. Both of these young men were so smart and had wonderful senses of humor and perspective. They were deep thinkers and had hearts of gold. So many times, other teachers would speak to me "sympathetically" that I "had" to have these boys in my class. Although there were times when I wanted to pull my hair (and they probably did too), most of the time, I loved being their teacher. Sometimes it is very difficult to see differences as something positive, especially when it means more work for us. But from my experience, these are the students that challenge us to become better teachers and better people.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Jennifer,
    I really enjoyed your post and unique perspective it gave on students with ADHD. I can relate to the "teacher's lounge talk," the negativity and bad reputation that is often unfairly attached to students with ADHD. While it may be challenging at times, my experience in working with students with ADHD has been extremely fun and rewarding. Like your article states, students with ADHD bring great energy and enthusiasm to the classroom and can be a great asset when given the right outlets and instruction. Like you, I was also inspired to research some of the great minds that have been diagnosed with ADHD. After watching the ADHD: Fact or Fiction video, I found that many of today's great creative thinkers, including CEOs and actors, struggle with ADHD yet still flourish and live very successful lives. I really enjoyed this article and your post for the positive light it brought to this topic.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Jennifer,

    I enjoyed reading this critique. It was really positive about students with ADHD. I do not have any students with ADHD, but this information is beneficial for the future. I think that is uncommon to find articles that express positive perspective of ADHD.

    ReplyDelete
  6. What a great article that has sparked wonderful conversation! I appreciate the connections you have made to your current teaching situation; and I am glad that you remain positive in your current setting.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Jennifer,
    I loved reading your post and I am very interested in reading this article! What an incredible outlook, to embrace the unique characteristics of students with ADHD and to not limit them. You made a comment in your post about how you avoid eating in the teachers lounge because of the negative talk that occurs regarding these same students. I think this is a great article that you should consider sharing and maybe even posting for your fellow educators to see...it could definitely shine some light :)

    ReplyDelete